Community

 

Which class is best suited to fat people? (Rather than just fit thin people?)

Last post 05-28-2008, 9:34 AM by luvanddaisies. 37 replies.
Page 3 of 3 (38 items)   < Previous 1 2 3
Sort Posts: Previous Next
  •  04-08-2008, 1:18 AM 26551 in reply to 26542

    Re: Which class is best suited to fat people? (Rather than just fit thin people?)

    yes I would be lost without my dietician, she's the one who requested I go on the lite n easy diet for six weeks but i've made an appt with my gp for next week, because I think after 6 months I should have had some sort of positive results!

    I waited the 6 months between measurements because I didn't want to obsess over kg and cms, but try to focus on fitness but it's a losing battle - I have ended up focussed on the darn numbers anyway, so maybe I need to do it more regularly.
     


    Hi, my first name is December. Really. It is.
    Current weight: 118kg (and falling)
  •  04-08-2008, 3:41 AM 26564 in reply to 26551

    Re: Which class is best suited to fat people? (Rather than just fit thin people?)

    i found it helped having closer intervals for me as i could see results and relate them to a good month or yes a bad one. Talk to your GP probably check ya thyroid to be certain that is not a problem.
  •  04-08-2008, 5:31 AM 26567 in reply to 26564

    Re: Which class is best suited to fat people? (Rather than just fit thin people?)

    I've been reading along with all of your posts, and the one thing I keep questioning is... Are you consuming enough calories?  That seems like a very low amount for anyone, let alone someone struggling with a weight problem.  Sometimes the key is to consume a little more or else your body will think you're starving it and go into holding on to every bit of fat there is.  I would definately check the thyroid, but you should also question the calorie amount.  It's just not enough.

    Good luck!  You're very inspirational!

    Carolyn

  •  04-08-2008, 6:37 AM 26576 in reply to 26567

    Re: Which class is best suited to fat people? (Rather than just fit thin people?)

    I have to agree with you on that point hence why i asked about seeing a nurtion expert. Your body needs fuel to burn fat ie you cannot start a fire with no matchs or flint hence wood never burns on its own
  •  04-08-2008, 7:15 AM 26602 in reply to 26576

    Re: Which class is best suited to fat people? (Rather than just fit thin people?)

    I don't know - my dietician wanted me on 1200 calories a day, but Lite N Easy refused to allow me to go that low because I was over 90kg in weight and I went on the 1500 calorie diet, and then added in 200 bonus calories for dessert.

    If my dietician doesn't know how many calories I should be eating per day, who should I turn to, to get that info from? Isn't a dietician a nutrition expert? I'm confused about what sort of specialist I should be seeing, now.

    I did have my thyroid checked 3.5 years ago (when I first started my health kick) and a year after that, and it came back normal each time, but I'll see what she says when I go and see her next week.

    Will keep you all updated!
     


    Hi, my first name is December. Really. It is.
    Current weight: 118kg (and falling)
  •  04-08-2008, 8:03 AM 26721 in reply to 26602

    Re: Which class is best suited to fat people? (Rather than just fit thin people?)

    Hi December,

     An online friend directed me here this morning and reading your thread inspired me to join!  LOL.

     Re: pump i wanted to say - look around you at the next class, look how much weight the instructor and really buff/practiced participants have on their bar.  Chances are you lift more than them EVERY STEP OF YOUR DAY.  So keep that in the forefront of your mind - even without a bar you are lifting WAY more than them.  If you put the same number of kgs as you're lifting just getting out of bed on a bar most of them wouldn't be able to lift it and none of them would be able to do a class with it.  From that point of view OF COURSE it will feel tough, but MY GOD, your courage and determination to get out there and do it should be a lesson to them and if it isn't it's THEIR loss.  I have been to classes with 3 different instructors and i LOVED two whereas the third had a style that suited some people, but not me (too school marm-ish), so it's definitely worth giving it another go.

     Re: the calories.  Yeah, usually one gets the daily need (that's your BMR (basal metabolic rate + calories for exercise you're doing) and subtracts 500/day for a weightloss of 0.5kg/week.  For someone your height and weight i would think just your BMR would be higher than 1500, never mind your total daily need.  Contrary to popular belief overweight people need MORE calories to retain weight.  In general an active person needs 12-15 calories per lb of weight to maintain their weight, whatever that weight is.  If you eat too little you CAN stall weightloss by making your body think you're starving and making it retain fat and eat muscle instead.  As for your question, that's a toughie.  Is there any way you can see a different nutritionist?  When a WEIGHTLOSS programme is contradicting your nutritionist's advice (i.e. the 1200 vs 1500 thing) it might be time for a second opinion. 

    When you're at the doctor ask if they will check you for poly cyctic ovary syndrome (i'm assuming you're a girl...?) as this frequently leads to insulin resistance and makes it MUCH harder to lose weight, but there are in that case medications that might help.  Also ask for adrenal testing.  It can't hurt.  I have a slow thyroid myself, getting to the bottom of these things can make such a big difference.

     Re: the kgs and cms gained...  Have you gained cms all over?  And did they use calipers to measure bodyfat or just a tape measure?  If i use a tape measure i've gained 3cm on each thigh and 1cm on each upper arm since last November (THANKYOU pump!!! :D) but if i use a caliper i can see it's muscle.  I've not gained any weight though, and my waist measurement is smaller.  Are any of your measurements smaller or are they all bigger?  You would expect 6 months of exercise to have increased muscle size and muscle is heavy, but equally you'd expect to see fat loss too.

     Finally, this is a big post so thanks for reading it all!  LOL.  Kepp on keeping on, you're doing a great job and you WILL see results soon.

     Bec

  •  04-08-2008, 7:22 PM 26743 in reply to 26602

    Re: Which class is best suited to fat people? (Rather than just fit thin people?)

    that sounds like real good advice to me and yes see a differnt dietician/nutrionist. get a diet that a will get you the desired weightloss that b is safe and finally promotes life long healthy eating otherwise the dreaded yo-yo effect might happen
  •  05-28-2008, 9:34 AM 30242 in reply to 26743

    Re: Which class is best suited to fat people? (Rather than just fit thin people?)

    So, how's it going?

    Hope you're still sticking with it and that you're feeling and seeing the benefits of your hard work at last.

    Keep it up!  Yes


    I've been invisible for a while - profile got deleted, so I'm back and 'friendless' with a post-count of about zero - so hello again everyone. Big Smile
Page 3 of 3 (38 items)   < Previous 1 2 3
View as RSS news feed in XML